Dr. Erie Tanja, postdoctoral researcher
Nowadays, when talking about scientific research, the call to make it multi- or interdisciplinary, is never far away. Although the terms are often mixed up or used interchangeably, there is a difference. Multidisciplinary research is about ‘simply’ combining insights from different disciplines; interdisciplinary research is the ‘symbiosis of disciplinary questions, methods and outcome measures’, transforming scientific identities in the process (De Jonge Akademie 2015). As so many researchers are trying to find out how to go from mono- to multi- and interdisciplinary research, it is necessary to share experiences and insights to prevent all of us from unnecessarily reinventing the wheel. In this blog, I want to do just that. Sharing my personal experience and viewpoints, means n=1 and that the perspective is inherently subjective. In the social sciences, such results would not merit much attention. But sharing and comparing experiences will help other researchers that conduct multi- or interdisciplinary research to find the way forward.
My PhD research in the field of political history, which addressed what constituted ‘good politics’ in the eyes of Dutch Members of Parliament (Tweede Kamerleden) in the period 1866-1940, was almost completely monodisciplinary in character. At the same time, a multidisciplinary approach came naturally to the topic. When looking at the development of written and unwritten political rules in this historical period, neglecting insights from the field of constitutional law would have meant putting blinkers on, as up until the turn of the 20th century constitutional law and parliamentary politics were strongly intertwined. In my PhD research, I used mainly theoretical insights from constitutional law (both modern and from the historical period itself), political science, and sociology in order to get a grasp on the development and meaning of parliamentary rules and conventions. I also belong to the group of political historians who believe that cooperation with political scientists might ask efforts from both sides, but is necessary and worthwhile (on the topic, see the inaugural lecture of Wim van Meurs, Never mind the gap). After my PhD, while working in the national public administration, I learned in practice how different (political or policy) perspectives can collide as well as reinforce each other, and how finding a solution can be both strenuous and straightforward. I therefore welcomed the opportunity to participate in a multidisciplinary project in which I could also use my practical experiences.
In 2017, the Faculty of Law, Economics and Governance of Utrecht University started an ambitious multidisciplinary research program, called Resilient Societies. It consists of nine projects, carried out by nine postdoctoral researchers in cooperation with different scholars from the three departments that form the Faculty. My postdoctoral research, on responsive governance, is part of a subprogram on Resilient Rule of Law. Although the goal was to ‘only’ perform multidisciplinary research, I have experienced the following three challenges that are often connected with doing interdisciplinary research: (1) how to balance between disciplines; (2) connecting different academic discourses; and (3) time investment.
The first challenge is how to find a balance between disciplines. In discussions on interdisciplinary research and especially interdisciplinary education, it is often stated that a firm monodisciplinary base is needed, before you can (or should) broaden your knowledge to other disciplines. I wholeheartedly agree: we can only build bridges between disciplines when scholars have a firm disciplinary base. This might seem counter-intuitive, but to relate to another perspective you need a point of departure with which the insights of other disciplines can be compared. Otherwise the risk is to get adrift, to lose one’s point of reference, and in that way make interdisciplinary research even more time consuming than it already is. Over the last year, I have sometimes felt like I was drifting between disciplines – I might have left my own disciplinary island, but have not yet found new dry land. Using another metaphor, that of the T-shaped professional (see Elaine Maks inaugural lecture on the T-shaped lawyer), in this case the T-shaped scientist, broadening before deepening means the danger of becoming top-heavy. Due to the physical shape of the T, there seems no risk of tilting or falling over – but the experienced weight can be too much. However, the fact that a firm disciplinary base is needed, does not mean that for multi- and interdisciplinary research to be successful, participants are at the same time required to look across the borders of their own discipline. Humor and a sense of perspective are also needed.
Secondly, an important question is to which academic discourse or debate interdisciplinary research must connect. This is a more fundamental issue than the question “where to publish?” The goal of interdisciplinary research is to bring the scientific debate further, going beyond monodisciplinary discourses and academic debates. But at the same time, you cannot bring a debate further if you do not relate to it. The challenge is how to reach a certain amount of depth in interdisciplinary research to be able to connect to a debate (or rather, multiple debates), bringing it further along and potentially transforming it. The primary value of interdisciplinary research lies in combining or integrating different scientific views. The risk, however, is that this integrated view only scratches the surface of a topic and does not reach an adequate amount of scientific depth. Moreover, something that is a complex issue in society does not become easier if you research it from an interdisciplinary angle. On the contrary, the question of the relative importance of different elements or insights becomes even more difficult to deal with. In the context of my own research, the enormous normative weight and fundamental and principled character of the rechtsstaat (rule of law) makes it very hard to transcend the legal debate. At the same time it is essential to transcend that debate, if we want to research the challenges that the rechtsstaat faces (that are often of a non-legal nature), and avoid that the rechtsstaat becomes seen as something for lawyers, and as an obstacle rather than an asset.
In the third place, for the reasons stated above, interdisciplinary research is very time consuming. It takes time to understand concepts, theories or methodologies and to know which academics are the leading ones in a field. This makes interdisciplinary research very much a team effort, and even then a slow effort. It also takes time to understand each other, and then some more time to bridge the gaps between the disciplines, which sometimes might even be a step too far. The fact that interdisciplinary research is time consuming is not a problem in itself – that comes with the territory. It does mean that when starting an interdisciplinary project, it is important to make sure that the objectives are clear and the conditions good.
As a last point, I would like to give some suggestions, that can make both multi- and interdisciplinary research easier:
- Start working from a concrete problem or specific topic, rather than starting at the theoretical or conceptual level or tackling a broad topic. Even concepts that are widely used in the social sciences and also in law such as norms or institutions, have different meanings in different disciplines and refer to different things. Bottom-up is easier than top-down.
- Think about the level of symbiosis you want to attain. Are insights to be combined (to prevent blind spots and deepen conclusions) or is the ambition to integrate them?
- Accept that the process might be like the dancing procession of Echternach: taking three steps forward, and two back again.
- Make it a team effort!
- Share experiences, the good ones and the bad.
Aw, this was a really nice post. In thought I wish to put in writing like this moreover – taking time and precise effort to make an excellent article… however what can I say… I procrastinate alot and under no circumstances appear to get one thing done.
Great site. Lots of useful info here. I¦m sending it to some pals ans additionally sharing in delicious. And obviously, thanks in your effort!
“This is very interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger. I have joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your great post. Also, I have shared your website in my social networks!”
auto loan 72 months
1.99 auto loan 72 months
auto loan
auto loan 72 months
auto loan 72 months
auto loan 72 months
auto loan
auto loan 72 months
Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on Building Bridges in the Brain, Behavioral, and Clinical Sciences; Pellmar TC, Eisenberg L, editors. Bridging Disciplines in the Brain, Behavioral, and Clinical Sciences. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 2000.
By the way! The best essay writing service – https://www.easyessay.pro/
And Happy New Year!
auto loan 72 months
auto loan
cephalexin price
advair
viagra soft 50mg
the general insurance quote
cheap auto insurance
cheap cephalexin
I have been exploring for a little for any high quality articles or blog posts in this sort of house . Exploring in Yahoo I eventually stumbled upon this site. Studying this info So i¦m happy to show that I have an incredibly excellent uncanny feeling I discovered just what I needed. I so much surely will make sure to do not overlook this website and give it a look regularly.
colchicine
advair buy
the general car insurance
general auto insurance
cephalexin 500mg
insurance quotes online comparison
colchicine price
insurance auto auctions
best car insurance company
advair
buy viagra soft tabs
female viagra
auto owners
where to buy keflex without prescription
auto loan
safe auto insurance
progressive quote
female version of viagra
colchicine 0.6mg
classic car insurance quote
cephalexin
auto insurance
buy viagra soft online
california auto insurance
auto insurance quotes online instant
first acceptance insurance
colchicine for pericardial effusion
auto insurance cheap
advair buy
viagra soft
colchicine
buy cephalexin
safe auto
colchicine acute gout
women viagra
cheap car insurance in pa
personal loans with bad credit
loans online instant approval
azithromycin 500
loans online
prednisolone
get a loan without a job
stromectol buy
personal loan interest rates
payday advance no credit check
loans online instant approval
stromectol
instant payday loan
advance payday
azithromycin for sale
loans rates
prednisolone 20 mg
prednisolone sodium phosphate
motilium 10mg
prednisolone 5mg
hydrochlorothiazide 125mg
payday loans
advance loans
loans online no credit check
stromectol 3 mg
payday advances
cash advance
personal loans
personal loans bad credit
payday advance online
motilium
ohio cash advance
buying hydrochlorothiazide
azithromycin without prescription
azithromycin
low cost loans
Very efficiently written article. It will be useful to anyone who utilizes it, as well as yours truly :). Keep up the good work – for sure i will check out more posts.
motilium domperidone
advance loans
hydrochlorothiazide 12.5mg
hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg tablets
motilium domperidone 10mg
buy motilium online
castle payday loans
personal loans guaranteed approval
hydrochlorothiazide online
buy online 10mg prednisolone
prednisolone sodium phosphate
guaranteed personal loan
motilium online
hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg
hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg price
loans online instant approval
online payday loans instant approval
1 hour loans
loans online
personal loan bad credit
loans instant approval
cheap prednisolone
purchase azithromycin 500 mg tablets
cash advance
generic hydrochlorothiazide
stromectol online
azithromycin 500 mg
online payday loans
cheap prednisolne
azithromycin
payday loans for bad credit
motilium online
cash advance online
lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide
loans with no credit
legitimate payday loans
fast auto loan
buy stromectol
personal loan form
motilium over the counter
buy prednisolone
hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg
hydrochlorothiazide
used auto loan rates
personal loans
loans online
bad credit loans guaranteed approval
motilium
hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg
loans online instant approval
used auto loan rates
loan refinance
cash advances
loans online
buy kamagra
private lenders
auto loan rates
robaxin 750
robaxin online
buy elimite online
cash advance loans
kamagra
personal loans
loans online instant approval
elimite
buy elimite
payday loans usa
cash advance 2017
buy vardenafil uk
loan no credit
advance payday
vardenafil 20mg tablets
personal loan bad credit
vardenafil
private lenders
kamagra oral jelly
generic kamagra
online payday loans instant approval
buy prednisone
robaxin 750 mg
parent loan
vardenafil
prednisone buy
personal loans
where to buy kamagra
kamagra
robaxin
cash advance loans
advance payday loans
advance loans
robaxin 500mg
elimite cream
kamagra oral jelly 100mg
buy prednisone online without a script
buy prednisone cheap
vardenafil 20 mg
vardenafil
loans online instant approval
price of vardenafil
elimite
personal lending
online payday loans instant approval
payday lending
online loans no credit check
lender
permethrin topical cream over counter
personal loans
elimite cream
online loans
buy prednisone
internet payday loans
webloan
personal loans low interest rates
personal loans
robaxin
robaxin 500
payday advance loan
buy prednisone
robaxin price
personal loan interest rates
loans instant approval
elimite cream ebay
poor credit loans guaranteed approval
low interest personal loans
same day payday loans no credit checks
loans no credit check
loans in tulsa
loans with no credit check
elimite
buy prednisone
prednisone 20mg by mail order
pay day loans
cheap kamagra
robaxin 750mg
generic vardenafil
auto car loan
prednisone without a prescription
robaxin
clomid male
mortgage lender
mortgage lenders of america
fluoxetine hcl 20mg
homework hotline
mortgage payoff
same day payday loans online
auto lenders
mortgage
mortgage payoff calculator extra principal
no prescription proventil inhaler
fluoxetine
auto loans online
no money down home loans
auto owners insurance online
reverse mortgage companies
va loan lenders
tadalafil 5mg
mortgage
apa writing
clomid
mortgage online
mortgage lenders
clomid for women
mortgage estimator calculator
national auto loan network
mortgage loans
mortgage
home loan lenders
home loan interest rates today
mortgage
tadalafil 20
mortgage
fluoxetine
buy clomid for men
fluoxetine 20 mg
accounting help
mortgage lenders of america
home loan experts
mortgage
clomid
tadalafil 20mg
best auto loan rates today
clomid for women
midland mortgage
tadalafil 5mg
live sex
mortgage amortization calculator
best mortgage
generic ventolin
sildenafil tablets 100mg
fluoxetine 10 mg
current va refinance rates
citrate sildenafil
community mortgage memphis
sildenafil citrate 100mg
mortgage
mortgage lender
ventolin
car loan interest rates
cost of prozac
home loan interest rate
mortgage
mortgage
best mortgage
sildenafil 100
sildenafil 100
reverse mortgage interest
nj mortgage
oklahoma mortgage
where to order clomid
mortgage lenders near me
prozac buy online
live porn
clomid online
mortgage
best mortgage rates
credit union home loan rates
buy clomid
best mortgage
home loan interest rate
community mortgage memphis
mortgage
mortgage
sildenafil tablets 100 mg
mortgage online
mortgage
mortgage
payday cash
mortgage
mortgage lender
study help
ventolin generic
ventolin hfa 90 mcg
live sex
mortgage lenders
buy fluoxetine online
mortgage lenders
mortgage
mortgage online
mortgage online
ventolin 90 mcg
sildenafil 100mg
buy clomid online usa
home loan mortgage
mortgage rates
best mortgage
tadalafil 5 mg
ventolin inhalers
home loan calculator
fluoxetine hcl
live porn cams
mortgage lenders of america
mortgage loans
buy clomid online without prescription
fluoxetine
a mortgage loan
ventolin hfa inhaler
mortgage
tadalafil 20 mg
mortgage lender
mortgage
mortgage
direct lenders immediate payment loans
my free cam
mortgage
home loans for veterans
california mortgage
prozac 20mg
mortgage lenders
home loan lenders
web cam girl
mortgage
trazodone 150 mg
atarax 25mg
trazodone 50 mg
porn live
mortgage rates 15
independent mortgage
mortgage
home loans
tetracycline online without prescription
best mortgage lenders
va loan limits
best mortgage lenders
order cipro online
best mortgage
no credit loans
avodart online
mortgage lenders of america
reverse mortgage
buy cipro cheap
mortgage
mortgage
trazodone 50 mg
mortgage lender
atarax
mortgage lender
home loans requirements
buy tetracycline online
mortgage loans
trazodone 150mg
generic dutasteride
mortgage
reverse mortgage
tetracycline 500 mg
buy tetracycline online without prescription
generic brand of avodart
atarax
mortgage lender
best mortgage
reverse mortgage loan
tetracycline online
live sex
mortgage
tetracycline 500 mg
va loans rates
trazodone tablets
home loans
community mortgage memphis
trazodone 100 mg
albuquerque mortgage
refinance mortgage rates
cipro
best mortgage lenders
cipro
50 mg of trazodone
mortgage investors group
list of home mortgage lenders
best mortgage lenders
mortgage
buy avodart
best mortgage
ciprofloxacin
mortgage lenders
mortgage lender
mortgages in canada
trazodone 50mg tablets
cipro
mortgage memes
auto insurance quote
live sex porn
avodart
va loan limits
best reverse mortgage lenders
va loan
trazodone
best mortgage
mortgage
mortgage solutions
mortgage online
avodart .5 mg
cipro
avodart
trazodone
generic avodart online
avodart generic
new mexico mortgage
reverse mortgage lenders
home loans with bad credit
mortgage lenders of america
tetracycline
mortgage
mortgage calculator
ciprofloxacin 500 mg
mortgage lender
mortgage rate
live porn cams
trazodone 50 mg
wellbutrin xl 300
cash advance
wellbutrin
cash advance
dapoxetine priligy
bupropion hcl sr
indocin indomethacin
dapoxetine 60mg
no credit check loans
bupropion xl 150 mg
seroquel generic
wellbutrin sr 150mg
direct lender payday loans
personal loan bad credit
bupropion hydrochloride
quick online loans instant approval
loans online no credit check
cash advance
cash advance
payday loans instant
dapoxetine for sale
indocin
buy dapoxetine
seroquel
payday loans direct lenders only
private money lenders
wellbutrin xl 150
credit personal loans
bad credit debt consolidation loans
buy seroquel generic
wellbutrin 150 xl
dapoxetine
bupropion xl 300mg
online loans no credit check
indocin sr 75 mg
direct lender payday loans
indocin
bupropion buy online
loans to build credit
dapoxetine buy online
guaranteed payday loan approval
bupropion
cash advance usa
bupropion
indocin indomethacin
credit personal loans
direct lender payday loans
wellbutrin 150 mg
indocin
dapoxetine premature ejaculation
personal loan interest rate
wellbutrin no prescription
payday loans direct lenders
dapoxetine
buy indomethacin
loan no credit check
christmas loan
dapoxetine
what is a payday loan
credit personal loans
loans with monthly payments
seroquel
order wellbutrin online
online pharmacy seroquel
payday cash advance
instant payday loans
bupropion sr
bupropion hcl sr
indomethacin
online payday loans instant approval
payday loans direct lenders only
wellbutrin
micro credit
seroquel 600 mg
credit personal loans
2000 loan
wellbutrin sr 150
cash advance
dapoxetine 30mg
payday loans direct lenders
bad credit loans
generic indocin
zoloft
no prescription zoloft
car insurance
auto insurance cost
car insurance comparison rates
propranolol
cheap car insurance quotes online
car insurance quotes online
propranolol 60 mg
car insurance quotes
buy lipitor online
sertraline zoloft
diflucan
liability car insurance
propranolol 40mg
lipitor
diflucan
direct auto insurance
online auto insurance
auto insurance cost
auto insurances
car insurance
auto insurance
buy auto insurance
need a loan with bad credit
eagle insurance
cheap strattera
buy diflucan
order zoloft
150 mg diflucan online
diflucan
strattera generic
buy propranolol
sertraline zoloft
buy auto insurance
buy auto insurance
propranolol 80 mg
diflucan online
cheap car insurance quotes online
car insurance companies
go auto insurance
gap insurance coverage
diflucan 150mg
buy auto insurance
aarp car insurance quote
online auto insurance
diflucan over counter
low cost car insurance
buy auto insurance
online car insurance
zoloft
general insurance quote
lipitor
allstate insurance quote
propranolol 10mg
stratera
compare car insurance quotes
auto insurance comparison
auto insurance rates
buy propranolol online
auto insurance
generic lipitor
auto insurance rates
auto insurance quote online
online car insurance quote
propranolol 40 mg
car insurance quotes comparison
auto acceptance insurance
sertraline
buy diflucan 150mg
car insurance quotes comparison
sertraline
cheap auto insurance in florida
amax insurance
cams
write my paper for me
albuterol
paper writing service
milf cams
albuterol
propecia generic finasteride
finasteride online
college paper writing service
professional writers
retin a 0.1
cams
essay paper writing service
albuterol mdi inhaler
cams
mfa creative writing
nolvadex
free sexting
paper writing service
amateur web cam
propecia finasteride
paper writing service
best retin a
buy nolvadex tamoxifen citrate
paper writing service
finasteride online
tretinoin gel
xxx web
retin a prescription
retin a cream 0.1
propecia online
best college paper writing service
free live sex cams
cams
albuterol inhaler
milf cams
live cam girls
paper writing service
valtrex
cams
adultchatavenue
free sex cams
writing assignment
bbw cams
generic valtrex
do my research paper
cams
wicked cam chat
retin a
albuterol pills for sale
valtrex medication
college paper writing
albuterol tablets
albuterol
write my paper
write my paper for me
buy valtrex no rx
free live sex cams
do my paper
nolvadex
cams
write my paper
cams
write my paper
valtrex
cams
cams
nolvadex online
write my paper
retin a
valtrex medication
cheap valtrex online
cams
write my assignment
writing my paper
loans with low interest rates
cams
nolvadex
live cam girls
cams
retin a cream 0.1
help me to write a book
girl cams
cams
write my paper
girl cams
albuterol sulfate
free live cams
help me write my paper
generic valtrex
retin a micro
retin-a cream 0.1
cams
write my paper for me
generic nolvadex
write my paper for me
write a paper for me
cams
girl cam
write my essay online
cheap allbuterol
write my paper
loans online no credit check
metformin 1000mg
installment loans for bad credit
loan
payday loan apr
advance loan
zovirax acyclovir
stromectol
personal loans for bad credit
personal loans for people with bad credit
online cash advance
a loan with bad credit
get a loan with bad credit
loan
buy proscar online
stromectol 3 mg
buy stromectol
metformin hcl
30 day payday loan
metformin hcl 500 mg
installment loans for bad credit
loan bad credit
fast loans no credit check
online loans no credit check
loans for bad credit
proscar
metformin hcl 500
payday advance loan
cash advance
proscar
payday loans no
metformin hcl
loans online
unsecured loans for bad credit
loans for students
loan websites
metformin hcl 500 mg without prescription
cost of proscar
metformin hcl
small personal loans with bad credit
stromectol 3mg
payday loans no credit
instant online payday loan
acyclovir
stromectol 3mg
lisinopril 40mg
cash loans for bad credit
zestril